Does Benevolent Leadership Always Lead to Organizational Citizenship Behavior? The Mediated Moderation Effect of Manipulative Intention and Trust

Lin, C. W., Hu, W. H., and Shih, J. B. 2017. Does Benevolent Leadership Always Lead to Organizational Citizenship Behavior? The Mediated Moderation Effect of Manipulative Intention and Trust. NTU Management Review, 27 (3): 33-64. doi:10.6226/NTUMR.2017.JAN.A102-062

Chia-Wu Lin, Professor, Department of Business Administration, National Dong-Hwa University
Wan-Hsien Hu, Part-Time Research Assistant, Department of Business Administration, National Dong Hwa University
Jian-Bin Shih, Assistant Professor, Department of Leisure and Recreation Management, Da-Yeh University

Abstract

Drawing on the attribution theory of leadership process, the subordinates’ attribution of intention about leaders’ behavior will affect their emotion and behavior. To address the attribution-consequence process, we hypothesize that perception of leaders’ manipulative intention moderated the positive relationship between benevolent leadership and trust, (i.e., in supervisor and organization) and organizational citizenship behavior, a mediated moderation model was proposed and tested. Two-wave data collected from 340 subordinates displayed results which demonstrated that benevolent leadership was less positively or even negatively related to trust and OCB when subordinates perceived high manipulative intention of their leaders’ behavior. On the contrast, benevolent leadership was positively related to trust and OCB when subordinates perceived low manipulative intention. Another finding is that benevolent leadership is most effective when they interact with the manipulative intention–the interaction effect on OCB partially mediated by trust in supervisor and organization. Finally, research limitations and suggestions for future research are also discussed. 


Keywords

attribution theorybenevolent leadershipmanipulative intentiontrustorganizational citizenship behavior


NTU Management Review No. 1, Sec. 4, Roosevelt Road, Taipei, 10617 Taiwan
3F, Bldg. 1, College of Management, National Taiwan University

TEL: +886-2-33661026  +886-2-33665404 | FAX: +886-2-23635658 | 

E-mail: ntupmcenter@ntu.edu.tw獲科技部人社中心補助

Subscription