Page 161 - 36-1
P. 161

In Taiwanese political practice, legislators are directly elected representatives of
                  the  people  who  hold  legislative  power.  Because  the  legal  basis  for  government
                  policies must be authorized by the legislature, legislators are motivated to serve their
                  constituents’  needs  and  to  pass  relevant  laws  to  secure  re-election  (Sheng,  1997).
                  Therefore, this study argues that firms that make political donations during elections
                  employ  a  more  direct  means  of  engaging  in  political  activism  in  exchange  for
                  potential political resources and benefits. Furthermore, following the implementation
                  of  the  Political  Donations  Act  in  Taiwan,  political  contribution  data  from
                  profit-seeking enterprises must be submitted to and publicly reported by the Control
                  Yuan,  providing  a  channel  to  identify  firms  that  engage  in  political  activism  and
                  approach  politicians.  This  study  hypothesizes  that  when  firms  engage  in  political
                  activism and seek to establish political connections with legislators, it may indirectly
                  influence the policy guidelines of administrative agencies. This could enable firms to
                  gain early access to political information, respond to future changes in the political
                  and economic environment, and strategize for innovative policies. However, corporate
                  political  activism  may  also  divert  funds  from  innovation  budgets  and  increase
                  political costs, making firms more vulnerable to political interference and creating a
                  “political  resources  curse.”  Therefore,  as  previous  research  has  not  yet  clearly
                                                          NTU Management Review Vol. 36 No. 1 Apr. 2026
                  outlined the advantages and disadvantages of corporate political activism on corporate
                  innovation,  this  study  focuses  on  corporate  political  activism  through  political
                  donations in legislative elections to investigate its impact on innovation capabilities.
                                           2. Research Design
                                              2. Research Design

                   This paper examines the impact of political activism on corporate innovation
                       This  paper  examines  the  impact  of  political  activism  on  corporate  innovation
               capabilities. Since corporate political activism is a self-selection behavior, firms can
                  capabilities. Since corporate political activism is a self-selection behavior, firms can
               choose whether to donate to legislators through political contributions. To minimize
                  choose whether to donate to legislators through political contributions. To minimize
               estimation bias, this study employs Heckman’s (1979) two-stage model. The first stage
                  estimation  bias,  this  study  employs  Heckman’s  (1979)  two-stage  model.  The  first
               uses a probit model to identify the factors influencing firms’ decisions to engage in
                  stage uses a probit model to identify the factors influencing firms’ decisions to engage
               political activism while controlling for election-year and industry fixed effects to calculate
                  in political activism while controlling for election-year and industry fixed effects to
                  calculate the inverse Mills ratio (IMR). The probit regression model is as follows:
               the inverse Mills ratio (IMR). The probit regression model is as follows:

                                                      )=     +               +                               +                        +                                          
                                           0   1              2              �  �  �  4              
                                  +               +                  +              +                                  
                                     �   �  �  �   �  �  �  �  �  �    �     �  �
                                                  �
                                          +                                          �  �  +                  +                                             
                                                                    ��
                                                                                     �  �
                                                         ��
                                                              �  �
                                     �
                                                  +                                                 +                  +                     
                                                                      ��
                                     ��
                                                           ��
                                                     �  �
                                                                            �  �
                                                                �  �
                                                                                            (1)
                                  + ∑                          + ∑                     .                                (1)

                   In the second stage, this study analyzes the impact of corporate political activism
                        In the second stage, this study analyzes the impact of corporate political activism
               on innovation capabilities by incorporating the IMR estimated in the first stage into the
                                                       23
                    on innovation capabilities by incorporating the IMR estimated in the first stage into the
               ordinary least squares regression to correct for self-selection bias. Political activism is
                    ordinary least squares regression to correct for self-selection bias. Political activism is
               proxied by whether firms engage in political donations (DONATE ) or by the amount
                                                                            i,k
                    proxied by whether firms engage in political donations (                         ) or by the amount
               of political contributions to legislators (DOS_F ). We measure corporate innovation
                                                                             ���
                                                           i,k
                    of political contributions to legislators (                   ). We measure corporate innovation
                                                             ���
               capabilities (the dependent variable) by using the adjusted number of patents (ADJ_
                    capabilities  (the  dependent  variable)  by  using  the  adjusted  number  of  patents
               PATENT ) and patent citations (ADJ_CITATION ) to eliminate time heterogeneity, based
                    (ADJ_                          )  and  patent  citations
                                                          i,t (ADJ_                                  )  to  eliminate  time
                      i,t
                                  ���
                                                                          ���
                    heterogeneity,  based  on  patents (         ) and  patent citations  (                 )  over  a  single
               on patents (PA ) and patent citations (CITA ) over a single period or subsequent years.
                            i,t
                                                      i,t
                                                                               ���
                                                    ���
                    period or subsequent years. Additionally, this study further controls for election year
               Additionally, this study further controls for election year and industry fixed effects and
                    and industry fixed effects and establishes the following regression model:
               establishes the following regression model:

                              (                          ) =      +                              ���   (                            )
                                            �
                      ���
                                                                  ���
                                       �
                                 ���
                                                    +                    +                         +                +                    ���  +                 
                                                       ���
                                                 �
                                                                      �
                                                                ���
                                                            �
                                                                                     ���
                                           ���
                                      �
                                                                                �
                                                    +                   +              +                          +                  +     (            ) �
                                      �    ���  �   ���  �       ���  ��    ���  ��       ���
                                                    +                    + ∑                          + ∑                      +      .                 (2)
                                                                                            (2)
                                                                      ���
                                      ��

                        This  study  further  examines  the  moderating  effect  of  differences  between
                   This study further examines the moderating effect of differences between electronics
                    electronics  and  non-electronics  industries  on  the  relationship  between  corporate
               and non-electronics industries on the relationship between corporate political activism
                    political activism and innovation capabilities. We assign a dummy variable equal to 1
                    if a firm belongs to the electronics industry and 0 otherwise. We analyze Innovation
                                                     153
                    capabilities of electronics across through interaction terms (                         ×                or
                                                                                  ���
                                                                                          ���
                                       ×              ), and the regression model is as follows:
                          ���
                                  ���

                              (                          ) =      +                                (                            )+                               ×             
                      ���        ���   �    �        ���          ���   �         ���     ���
                                                        (                             ���  ×              ) +                    +                    +                       
                                                             �
                                                                  ���
                                                                                        ���
                                                                                  �
                                                                            ���
                                                                        �
                                                       ���
                                         +                +                    ���  +                  +                  +             
                                                                                ��
                                                                      �
                                                                          ���
                                                                                    ���
                                       �
                                           ���
                                                           �
                                                                ���
                                                 �
                                                      +                           +                  +     (            ) �  +                 
                                       ��      ���   ��    ���  ��       ���  ��
                                                      + ∑                          + ∑                      +      .                          (3)
                                                             ���


                                                   3. Findings

                        This study analyzes listed firms in Taiwan from 2008 to 2019 to examine how
                    corporate political activism impacts innovation capabilities. We manually collect data
                    on political donations made by profit-seeking enterprises to legislators from Control
                    Yuan, using them as a proxy for political activism. We also compile patent and patent
                    citation  data  from  the M-Trends  Patent  search  and  analysis  system,  and  utilize  the
                    number of patents held and cited by Taiwanese firms at the United States Patent and
                    Trademark  Office  (USPTO)  as  proxies  for  corporate  innovation  capabilities
                    (Hagedoorn and Cloodt, 2003). The results reveal a significant negative relationship
                                                        24
   156   157   158   159   160   161   162   163   164   165   166